

Julie Burchill, the media commentator known for her outrageous, often offensive and contentious opinions, has stirred up another hornets’ nest. She has had her book ‘Welcome to the Woke Trials: How #Identity killed progressive politics’ due out in March, dropped by publishers Little, Brown after a row with Muslim journalist Ash Sarkar. She was accused of ‘crossing a line’ by posting ‘Islamophobic’ comments on Twitter. Burchill had tweeted that Sarkar’s worship of the Prophet Mohammed was the ‘worship of a paedophile’, referring to the 7th Century leader’s marriage to his third wife Aisha when she was around 10.
Born 3 July 1059 Bristol, England, Burchill is a Sun Cancer opposition Saturn, sextile Pluto and trine – so an odd mix of under-confident and utterly unyielding. What causes the problems is her Mercury, Uranus, Mars spread out through Leo which will make her attention-grabbing, explosive, uncompromising; and with her Mars squaring Jupiter she’ll be a risk-taker and impulsive. She’s not a happy camper from later this month to late January with a major disruption from tr Uranus square her Sun/Pluto midpoint; followed by a disastrous two years of scary, risky tr Pluto square her Mars/Saturn midpoint.
It may or may not blow up into a “Satanic Verses” Rushdie standoff but even if it doesn’t will provoke similar arguments.
In 1988 author Salman Rushdie had to go into hiding with heavy security after death threats were made against him for a novel that Westerners would not have raised an eyebrow over. Joan Bakewell remarked at the time it was a problem for a basically tolerant country when it takes in intolerant elements – it doesn’t know what to do with them. The UK has no interdict against blasphemy, while Islam does. And it’s why the rigorously secular French made such a stand over Charlie Hebdo, ditto the Danes over the Muhmmad cartoons.
There was an excellent book years back by, I think a Norwegian journalist, about the position of modern women in Islamic countries which certainly included detail about Muhammad’s complicated marital history. She was not popular but whether she spent the rest of her life in hiding I don’t know.
Ash Sarkar is a left-wing journalist and political activist, 17 April 1992, and has an Aries with a super-determined Pluto trine Mars, sextiling onto a highly strung Uranus Neptune in Capricorn. She enjoys jousting with Burchill in a fight for the upper hand and last word with both their respective Jupiters and Pluto colliding. And Sarkar’s Pluto squares Burchill’s Mars for a hostile clash.
In some ways it’s a spat in a teacup. But it also highlights an unresolved and unresolvable problem about respect for other cultures/religions when they don’t offer respect for the mores of the country they choose to live in.